Apostrophes, Sigh

What is it with apostrophes? They show up when they aren’t needed and go AWOL when they are. Here’s an example from the first category, in a blurry photo I snapped from a moving car:

Unless the HOUSES & LAND belong to a man named JOHN BUY, this apostrophe interrupts a perfectly good verb.

Another unnecessary apostrophe, in the plural noun Mondays:

Whoever made this sign tried a tactic I’ve often seen students employ: miniaturizing the punctuation mark. The student hopes that if the word needs an apostrophe, the teacher will see one, and if it doesn’t, the teacher will see an untidy smudge. I should note that hedging a punctuation bet this way never works, in class or in signs.

Now for the AWOL Department. This sign, in an elevator serviced by a major airline that should know better, lacks an apostrophe:

There are more problems with this sign than writing FIREMANS instead of FIREMAN’S. First of all, I sincerely hope that more than one person would respond to a blaze in an airport. A blaze anywhere, for that matter! Thus I have a problem with FIREMAN, a singular noun. Second, the sign has a gender problem. If I were a FIREFIGHTER (a more accurate and inclusive term), I’d be tempted to thwack this sign with my extinguisher and put a dent in FIREMANS.

This one is in a category all by itself:

I wonder what sort of goals a numeral can have. Does 1 aspire to become 2? Aim for 10? Perhaps 1 aspires to a fancier font?

Maybe there’s a 1 somewhere in the world striving to curtail gun violence. I can get behind that last goal, for sure, and you probably can, too. If only the shop displaying this sign could help us refine that goal and create an action plan. That would undoubtedly be in EVERY 1’S best interest.

8 thoughts on “Apostrophes, Sigh

  1. William Cooper

    Gerry: Before I ponder the answer to your question about erratic apostrophes, I want to know why Apple Mail had been sending Grammarian in the City emails to my junk mailbox. I only became aware of this email because, thanks to Apple’s erratic behavior, the email for this post made it to my inbox. I had previously noticed the absence of emails but didn’t check my junk mailbox until now. Sigh!

    Reply
    1. Geraldine Post author

      Hi, Bill. I don’t know why Apple Mail diverted the Grammarian in the City notices. Wish I did, because then I could improve my own email sorting.

      Reply
  2. Ellie Presner

    Ah yes, the ‘untidy smudge’ hedge reigns supreme!
    The misuses of an apostrophe is one of my chief pet peeves. Another fellow blogger dubbed it the ‘apostrophe catastrophe.’!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *